Chapter One: Arts Integration
Background: Arts in Schools
Many teachers, schools, and arts programs benefit from knowing the different ways the arts can be present in schools. Without making a distinction, opportunities can be missed, programs can lack clarity, or the arts can seem like something too unwieldy to incorporate. Making a distinction among the approaches can help narrow or focus objectives as well as help educators select the most appropriate approach based on their objectives. Ultimately, students are best served when all three variations-Arts as Curriculum, Arts-Enhanced Curriculum, and Arts-Integrated Curriculum-are part of their education (Figure 1.1).
The arts find their way in to elementary, middle, and high school classrooms every day in a variety of ways. The variations can be distilled into three main categories:
• Arts as Curriculum
• Arts-Enhanced Curriculum
• Arts-Integrated Curriculum
All three variations are important, needed, and valid. All benefit from being supported by arts experiences-where students attend performances and exhibits by professional artists to engage in authentic experiences that deepen and broaden their arts understandings.
Figure 1.1. Arts in Schools
While the three variations naturally link and support each other, there are reasons why teachers and schools target one or more approaches. Understanding the differences in the approaches can help teachers and schools make informed choices about the programs they offer.
Art as Curriculum
If a school has a music, art, drama, or dance teacher, their approach is most likely and primarily Arts as Curriculum. Students develop knowledge and skills in a particular art form. Often referred to as "arts learning" or "art for art's sake," the programs are guided by national, state, or local standards for each of the art forms. For example, in visual arts, students learn the content, processes, and techniques for two- or
three-dimensional work. They learn how the visual arts developed and changed throughout history and engage in creating and analyzing works created in a variety of media.
When the arts are used as a device or strategy to support other curriculum areas, but no objectives in the art form are explicit, then the approach is called Arts-Enhanced Curriculum. For example, students sing the ABCs as a means to other ends-remembering the letters and sequence of the alphabet. However, students are not usually expected to learn about melody, song structure, or develop specific singing skills. Arts-Enhanced Curriculum acts as a "hook" to engage students in learning content. Additionally, teachers need little or no training in the art form. Arts-Enhanced Curriculum is often mistaken for Arts-Integrated Curriculum or a distinction is not made between the two.
In Arts-Integrated Curriculum, the arts become the approach to teaching and the vehicle for learning. Students meet dual learning objectives when they engage in the creative process to explore connections between an art form and another subject area to gain greater understanding in both. For example, students meet objectives in theater (characterization, stage composition, action, expression) and in social studies. The experience is mutually reinforcing-creating a dramatization provides an authentic context for students to learn more about the social studies content and as students delve deeper into the social studies content their growing understandings impact their dramatizations. For Arts-Integrated Curriculum to result in deep student understanding in both the art form and the other curriculum area, it requires that teachers engage in professional development to learn about arts standards and how to connect the arts to the curriculum they teach.
Arts Integration Definition
Arts integration is an approach to teaching in which students construct and demonstrate understanding through an art form. Students engage in a creative process, which connects an art form and another subject area and meets evolving objectives in both.
Inside the Definition
Arts Integration is an APPROACH to TEACHING...
approach (n)-a path, road, or other means of reaching a person or place
This definition begins with the assertion that arts integration is larger than an activity. Rather, arts integration is an approach to teaching that is embedded in one's daily practice.
An "approach to teaching" refers to how something is taught rather than what is taught. Every teacher has an approach to teaching, whether or not they are aware of it. Approaches fall along a continuum from traditional, teacher-centered instruction to more progressive, student-centered instruction. Ultimately, our approach is based on our beliefs about how students learn. As an approach to teaching, arts integration relies heavily on the progressive, student-centered end of the continuum.
This approach to teaching is grounded in the belief that learning is actively built, experiential, evolving, collaborative, problem-solving, and reflective. These beliefs are aligned with current research about the nature of learning and with the Constructivist learning theory. Constructivist practices that align with arts integration practices include:
• Drawing on students' prior knowledge;
• Providing active hands-on learning with authentic problems for students to solve in divergent ways;
• Arranging opportunities for students to learn from each other to enrich their understandings;
• Engaging students in reflection about what they learned, how they learned it, and what it means to them;
• Using student assessment of their own and peers' work as part of the learning experience;
• Providing opportunities for students to revise and improve their work and share it with others;
• Building a positive classroom environment where students are encouraged and supported to take risks, explore possibilities, and where a social, cooperative learning community is created and nurtured.
Students Construct and Demonstrate UNDERSTANDING...
understand-(1) to get or perceive the meaning of; to know or grasp what is meant by; comprehend (2) to gather or assume from what is heard; to infer 3) to know thoroughly; grasp or perceive clearly and fully the nature, character, functioning, etc. of 4) to have a sympathetic rapport with
Constructing understanding of one's world is an active, mind-engaging process. Information must be mentally acted upon in order to have meaning for the learner (Brooks & Brooks, 1999).
Arts integration provides multiple ways for students to make sense of what they learn (construct understanding) and make their learning visible (demonstrate understanding). It goes beyond the initial step of helping students learn and recall information to challenging students to take the information and facts they have learned and do something with them to build deeper understanding.
"In the arts students have central and active roles as meaning makers. This role demands that they not only acquire knowledge but they develop the capacity to reflect on what they are learning and to use it as they interpret and create works of art" (Stevenson & Deasy, 2005, p. 37).
Students' visible demonstrations of learning serve as both formative assessments to guide instruction and summative assessments to determine what students have learned. For example, when students are challenged to work as choreographers to create a dance that demonstrates how the seasons change, they must build their understanding of the vocabulary and concepts shared by science and dance (such as rotate, revolve, cycles, patterns, and change). Their dance will reflect their understandings and provide teachers with a quick, effective means to determine whether individual students know the difference between rotate and revolve, if a group understood the cyclical nature of the seasons, or if the class has mastered how to demonstrate the concept of change through physical movement.
... Through an ART FORM
art form (n)-any branch of creative work in the arts (visual arts, dance, drama, music); the products of creative work
Students can construct and demonstrate their understanding in many ways. Traditionally, they are asked to communicate their learning through a report or on a test. However, when they are involved in arts integration, their learning is evident in the products they create, such as the dance, painting, or dramatization.
Students can-and should-have opportunities to construct and demonstrate their understandings in various ways. Nationwide, classrooms have become, and continue to become, more culturally, economically, and academically diverse. And yet, a great deal of instruction relies primarily, and sometimes exclusively, on speaking and writing as the way for students to show what they know. Today's research points to the power of learning through a variety of senses or modalities. Teachers are encouraged to plan instruction that engages students in visual, aural, and kinesthetic learning modalities so that students can actively process what they are learning. The recognition of the arts as powerful modalities for learning is embedded in this part of the definition. By their nature, the arts engage students in learning through observing, listening, and moving and offer learners various ways to acquire information and act on it to build understanding. They also offer a natural way to differentiate instruction as the arts offer multiple modes of representation, expression, and engagement (Wolf, 2008). Additionally, the arts provide an authentic context in which students solve problems such as those encountered by professional artists.
Students Engage in a CREATIVE PROCESS...
creativity (n)-an imaginative activity fashioned so as to produce outcomes that are original and of value (NACCC, 2007).
The heart of arts integration is engagement in the creative process. Arts integration requires that students do more than repeat (a song), copy (an art project), or follow directions. They must create something that is original and of value. The creative process in the arts is a process not a single event. It includes many interacting phases and each phase is related to every other (Robinson, 2001). There are many descriptions of the creative process. The one provided here is a synthesis of ideas from many different sources. In this diagram (Figure 1.2), the process is made visible as five open circles: 1) students imagine, examine, and perceive; 2) they explore, experiment, and develop craft; 3) they create; 4) they reflect, assess, and revise, and 5) share their products with others. Arrows indicate the ways one can enter the process and the myriad ways the phases interact.
Figure 1.2. Arts Integration Creative Process
When students engage in the creative process, they produce original work that communicates their ideas, insights, points of view, and feelings. The creative process can be "messy." It is difficult to predict what
will happen, be discovered, or emerge during the process. Learners engage in inquiry and experimentation as opposed to following rigid, step-by-step rules. Some ideas, once explored, do not work well, while other ideas that were not originally considered, may surface as the perfect solution. If teachers are overly concerned with a "neat" process and product, they tend to make the creative choices for students and direct the outcome. In these cases, the creative process is present, but only for the teacher. It is the teacher's or teaching artist's responsibility to set a creative problem or challenge for students to solve, but not to take over and solve the challenge for the students.
...Which CONNECTS an art form and Another Subject Area...
connect (v)-to join, link, or fasten together; unite or bind
Figure 1.3. Arts Integration Interdisciplinary Connections
A distinguishing aspect of arts integration is its interdisciplinary connections. Connections are made between a specific art form and a specific curriculum area (Figure 1.3). For example, collage can be connected to the study of geographical regions or choreography can be connected to the study of life cycles. Connections can also be made between a specific art form and a school's concern or need. Schools often identify a focus for improvement that is sometimes outside the formal curriculum. For example, the arts can connect to school concerns such as character education/bullying, collaboration, habits of mind, or multiple intelligences.
Both connections-to curriculum or a concern/need-are strongest when they are mutually-reinforcing. In other words, by engaging in learning in one subject, learning in the other subject is reinforced and extended, and vice versa. Rather than imagining connections as two intersecting lines, mutually-reinforcing connections function as a cycle.
For example, students are challenged to create a tableau (motionless stage picture) that depicts a defining moment of the Trail of Tears. They must examine the social studies content, find out what led to the United States government forcibly relocating the Native Americans west of the Mississippi River, and determine the impact the dislocation had on the Native Americans. They must then distill their understandings into a tableau, which requires them to consider stage composition, characters, actions, relationships, and expression. Because a tableau is so concise, students must return to the social studies curriculum to determine the most significant information. Once the tableau is created, students are challenged to compose short statements that they will speak within the tableau. Again, they must return to the social studies content, synthesize it, and make inferences. With each rotation through the cycle, student learning in both theatre and social studies is reinforced and deepened. The more they learn about the Trail of Tears, the more their tableaus develop; the more their tableaus develop, the more they build their understanding of history.
... and meets EVOLVING OBJECTIVES in both. evolve (v)-to develop gradually Figure 1.4. Arts Integration Evolving Objectives
This final part of the definition underscores two ideas. First, arts integration requires teachers to set objectives in both the art form and the other subject area. The dual objectives are balanced; students are accountable for significant learning in both the art form and the other subject. Second, just as objectives evolve (Figure 1.4) and challenge students to deepen their understandings in science, math, or language arts, objectives in the art form must also evolve if students are to remain challenged. A student does not learn to express ideas through dance in one session. As students master each objective, they are ready to take on the next, more challenging ones. Teachers monitor student progress and adjust objectives to keep students challenged and interested within a unit or across a year. As students' mastery grows, so do their feelings of self-efficacy-the belief in oneself and one's ability to achieve.
Teachers are familiar with the evolving nature of objectives in math, language arts and other subject areas. They are less familiar with evolving objectives in the arts. Here is an example in dance:
• The objective is for students to create and perform a movement phrase set to a piece of music. This objective can begin with small groups of students choosing their movement phrase from a limited set of options and where the teacher counts the beat aloud. Once mastered, the objective evolves as students create their own movement phrase without pre-set options and can recall and repeat it. The objective further evolves as students are able to count the beat on their own. The objective evolves again as students are challenged to refine the quality of their movements. The evolution of objectives can pertain to one specific experience with a dance or can evolve as students have multiple experiences with dance across a school year.
Arts Integration Checklist
Some educators confuse any effort to include the arts in their classroom with arts integration. While all types of arts-based instruction are encouraged, it is helpful for educators to know when they are engaged in arts integration. To achieve this awareness, an Arts Integration Checklist (Figure 1.5) is provided. Educators answering "yes" to the items in the Checklist can be assured that their approach to teaching is indeed integrated.
Figure 1.5. Arts Integration Checklist Approach to Teaching
• Are learning principles of Constructivism (actively built, experiential, evolving, collaborative, problem-solving, and reflective) evident in my lesson?
• Are the students engaged in constructing and demonstrating understanding as opposed to just memorizing and reciting knowledge?
• Are the students constructing and demonstrating their understandings through an art form? Creative Process
• Are the students engaged in a process of creating something original as opposed to copying or parroting?
• Will the students revise their products?
• Does the art form connect to another part of the curriculum or a concern/need?
• Is the connection mutually reinforcing? Evolving Objectives
• Are there objectives in both the art form and another part of the curriculum or a concern/need?
• Have the objectives evolved since the last time the students engaged with this subject matter?
Brooks, J. G., & Brooks, M. G. (1999). In search of understanding: The case for constructivist classroom.
Alexandria, VA: ASCD.
NACCC (National Advisory Committee on Cultural and Creative Education). (2007). In P. Cochrane & M. Cockett, Building a creative school: A dynamic approach to school development (p. 7). Stoke on Trent, UK: Trentham Books.
Robinson, S. K. (2001). Out of our minds: Learning to be creative. West Sussex, England: Capstone Publishing.
Stevenson, L. M., & Deasy, R. (2005). Third space: When learning matters. Washington, DC: Arts Education Partnership.
Wolf, D. P. (2008). Building and evaluating freedom machines: When it arts education a setting for equitable learning? In D. Glass (Ed.), Contours of inclusion: Frameworks and tools for evaluating arts in education (pp. 5-6). Washington, DC: VSAarts.
Arts integration: Useful resources on how you can integrate arts in the classroom. Retrieved from https://www.pinterest.com/edutopia/arts-integration/
Dorminey, S. (2015). Arts integration in a middle grades social studies classroom. Retrieved from https://digitalcommons.georgiasouthern.edu/honors-theses/87/
Fung, J. (2013). What to do when the arts are missing from your school. The Teaching Channel. Retrieved from:_https://www.teachingchannel.org/blog/2013/05/17/arts-integration/
Jenson, E. (2012). The arts as a major discipline. Retrieved from
Lajevic, L. (2012). Arts integration: What's really happening in the elementary classroom? Retrieved from https://escholarship.org/uc/item/9qt3n8xt
Reif, N., & Grant, L. (2010). Culturally responsive classrooms through art integration. Journal of Praxis in Multicultural Education, 5(1). Retrieved from
Riley, S. (2012). Using arts integration to enhance the common core. Retrieved from http://www.edutopia.org/blog/core-practices-arts-integration-susan-riley
Ross, C. (2008). Art integration in the classroom. Retrieved from https://epublications.regis.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1100&context=theses
Schwarts, K. (2015, January 23). How integrating arts into other subjects makes learning come alive. Retrieved from https://www.kqed.org/mindshift/38576/how-integrating-arts-into-other-subjects-makes-learning-come-alive
Sorensen, M. (2010). Integrating art and literacy in the elementary classroom. Retrieved from https://scholarworks.uni.edu/hpt/30
Tilney, V. (2013). The arts matter. Retrieved from http://www.scholastic.com/teachers/article/arts-matter
Why integrating art into the classroom may improve retention? (2011). Retrieved from http://artplantaetoday.com/2011/09/30/why-the-arts-improve-content-retention/
Yarnbes, L. (2015, June 6). A teacher's experience with arts integration in the classroom [Web Blog Post]. Retrieved from http://blogs.getty.edu/iris/a-teachers-experience-with-arts-integration-in-the-classroom/
BOOKS A VAILABLE AT DALTON STATE COLLEGE LIBRARY
Edwards, L. C. (2006). The creative arts: A process approach for teachers and children (4th ed.). Upper Saddle River, NJ: Pearson/Merrill/Prentice Hall.
Goldberg, M. R. (2006). Integrating the arts: An approach to teaching and learning in multicultural and multilingual settings (3rd ed.). Boston, MA: Pearson/Allyn & Bacon.
Smith, R. A. (2006). Culture and the arts in education: Critical essays on shaping human experience. New York, NY: Teachers College Press.
Arts integration: Deepening understanding of core content [Video file]. (2016). Edutopia. Retrieved from https://youtu.be/IUsWCdu9Q_Q
Hard fun: Transforming education through the arts [Video file]. (2013). Retrieved from http://youtu.be/LRQ4ay0Ot9U?list=PL3E8AC8BA0EFC8223
Infusion arts in education: Using arts to learn [Video file]. (2012). Retrieved from https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jLpI9T8dZYM
Lavine Production Group. (2003). The Arts in every classroom: A video library, K-5. S. Burlington, VT: Annenberg/CPB.
Teaching through the arts programme [Video file]. (2014). Retrieved from https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vsFR1_KlYmo
The power of arts integration: Series overview [Video file]. (2015). Retrieved from https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9XcIg3eX2FY
The state of the arts in America's schools [Video file]. (2000). Retrieved from Films on Demand database.
SCHOLARLY JOURNAL ARTICLES
Daniel, V. A. H., Stuhr, P. L., & Ballengee-Morris, C. (2006). Suggestions for integrating the arts into curriculum. Art Education, 59(1), 6-11.
Holmes, S. A. (2002). Creative by nature: Integrating the arts into environmental science education. Green Teacher, 2(69), 23-28.
Lynch, P. (2007). Making meaning many ways: An exploratory look at integrating the arts with classroom curriculum. Art Education, 60(4), 33-38.
Vitulli, P., Santoli, S. P., & Fresne, J. (2013). Arts in education: Professional development integrating the arts and collaborating with schools and community. International Journal of Pedagogies & Learning, 5(1), 45-52.